Just as a warning, before you get too far into this post (and boy, is this one a monster), for those of you who haven't read
Church & State Volume 2; I am going to spoil the ending. Feel free to read up until the point when I say Spoiler!!! I thought a little bit about this, and I really have to. Sorry. In the introduction the the
Church & State epilogue story in
Cerebus Number Zero, Dave Sim gives away some of the details of the ending himself, but I'm going all the way. With specifics. Be forewarned.
This monster of a book finishes off the massive
Church & State storyline that covers over 1200 pages of comic books, and unfolded over the course of 4 years or so worth of monthly comics. A lot of people will point to this story as the peak achievement of Dave Sim's career, and I'd be hard pressed to argue. I already mentioned that
High Society was my favorite, but there's not a lot out there that can match the scope, ambition, and audacity of
Church & State. The upcoming
Mothers & Daughters storyline is probably the next closest contender, in terms of ambition and density, but for a lot of reasons, it falls flat on it's face in ways that are disappointingly avoidable.
I keep getting ahead of myself here...it's hard to avoid with a project of this size. Sorry. And there's a lot of plot recapping to come...sorry for that too.
So Volume 2 picks up with Cerebus seemingly usurped from his position as Pope by a giant stone monstrosity (who we met much earlier, in the first book) named Thrunk. Cerebus is deposed, abandoned by Sophia, rejected by Jaka, thrown from his hotel, quite literally. He's pretty much at rock-bottom as this volume begins, his most loyal follower having just stabbed himself to death.
And as if things couldn't get any worse, here comes the Cockroach again.
This time we're treated to Secret Sacred Wars Roach, clad in a black skintight costume with a white spider emblem across his chest and ribs. The McGrew Brothers are in on his delusion this time as well, forced by physical violence and sheer force of insanity into roles as his white costumed henchmen, reciting the overwrought narration that is a hallmark of any Roach encounter. I think this is the most impenetrable Roach-persona so far. All the comic book superheroes he's lampooned so far have worked well on their own, with no knowledge of the specific character required to enjoy the Roach as a character (of course, familiarty helps with a few of the in-jokes). But Secret Sacred Wars? We're dipping our toes into obsessive fanboy references here. I'd never read a single page of Moon Knight comics and had no trouble with the Moon Roach, but somehow, Secret Sacred Wars Roach doesn't work quite as effortlessly. It feels like there are references here that are meangingless without context. His actions work just fine on a plot level, but the asides are a little more obscure...
The majority of the first section of the book is feeding us information, most notably on the Final
Ascension, the potentially disatrous event that everything has been building to. We learn that Adam Weisshaput's plans are being carried out after his death, and that since he won't be ascending himself, he wants Cerebus to be the one (for completely selfish reasons, of course). But his post-mortem assistance does help Cerebus regain control of the populace, and re-take his hotel from the false Pope, Thrunk. But only after a fast-paced race up a sheer cliff-face, with Cerebus trailing the Cockroach (and Elrod!) as they scramble towards the Upper City. Astoria is waiting at the top, only to be mysteriously and magically whisked away by an oblivious Cerebus' command.
And to compliacte matters somewhat, she's apaprently magically whisked away to the chambers of the Lion of Serrea, the Eastern Pontiff, who she is compelled to assassinate.
With Cerebus the pope of a newly united Church, and Astoria in jail for the murder of a pontiff, we come to the real tour-de-force of Church & State. Several issues are devoted to Cerebus' interrogation of Astoria, while the clock ticks away to her midnight trial (and assumed execution, sealing Cerebus' position).
We learn many things, and for the first time in
Church & State, we get an actual discussion of opposing religious philosophies. For though Cerebus has the apparent upper hand over Astoria, who has helped him almost as much as she's used him as a political tool, she still has plenty of power in this situation. For starters, the Church wants Astoria killed not just for the Lion's murder, but also so that they can be rid of any doubts of her influence, as the leader of an upstart feminist political philosophy called Kevillism, over Cerebus. And a Church with such a high mortality rate among pontiffs is not a Church you want to defy.
But then again, If he does go along with the Church's wishes, and sentences Astoria to death, he'll have to contend with Cirin, the leader of the other influential female centered faction in Estarcion. Astoria is a former disciple of Cirin's, whose desertion of Cirin's cause is still a sore spot for the matriarch. Cirin wants Astoria's death on no-one's hands but her own, and she has the military power to take on the Church if it comes down to it.
While awaiting trial, we learn a bit more about the opposing female-centered ideologies that are in play here. Cirinism is a matriarchal form of fascism, centered on "traditional family values" and the importance of motherhood. Men are considered second-class citizens under a Cirinist rule, and live births are a woman's highest calling, with Mothers valued above Daughters in the social heirarchy. Kevillism, on the other hand, values individual freedom above all, allowing for women to prevent or abort pregnancies, among other things. It's not much more charitable towards men, either. Both philosophies are basically rooted in a Goddess-centered religion, cast in opposition to the dominant Church of Tarim that we've seen to date. Their religion is essentially a female-centric recasting of Tarim as Terim. There's much more detail given to both philosophies in the upcoming volumes of
Mothers & Daughters, but this is where we get a broader sense of the movements.
One of the more disturbing scenes in
Church & State takes place before Astoria's trial as well: her rape. One of her methods of bartering with Cerebus for her release was to dangle the possiblity of physical intimacy (and remember, Cerebus has been left by his "wife" and recently found out that Jaka is married). Of course, she teases, that's not something the pope can do outside of marriage. Cerebus' solution? He re-blindfolds and gags Astoria. He declares his marriage to Sophia dissolved. He declares Astoria his wife. And, in a series of panels consisting of lettering only, he has his way with her in her prison cell. And then declares them divorced.
Now, obviously this is a pretty brutal and shocking sequence, even if it is executed with a minimum of graphic detail. And I don't think it's gratuitous, seeing as it's perfectly in character for Cerebus (I mean, jeez...he threw a cripple off a roof and tossed a baby into a crowd already during his tenure as pope!). Already, we've seen our protagonist as everything from thief to murderer to soldier to politician to priest, so why not add rapist? He's been shown as pretty consistently amoral and self-interested. (And please note, this is not to excuse or condone the actions of the character, but simply it's presence in the story.)
But to get what's really odd and creepy about this scene (beyond the fact that we're actually supposed to sympathize with a rapist for the next 175 issues or so) requires a little outside knowledge: that Astoria is reportedly based on Sim's now-ex-wife. There are real depths of unease in this scene when it's approached with this knowledge, and I think it's a small indicator of things to come. As this story progresses, there's much more evidence of how deeply Sim's dealings with women affect his outlook on the world. I'm not suggesting that his divorce is a root cause, but I think it was part of a series of events that pushed a lot of ideas to the forefront of his mind, and a lot of these ideas start showing up first as subtext, before they start to consume the series in a more overt way.
Importantly, I think this scene is one of several that mark a shift of focus, away from power struggles in general (and in which the participants are mostly male) that have characterized the first several books, and begin to focus more on gender-related struggles, notably in
Mothers & Daughters' most infamous passages, and again in
Guys. But again, I'm getting ahead of myself. We've still got more
Church & State to deal with, and 2 other books to go before this becomes the central theme.
Next up, after all this build-up, comes Astoria's actual trial. Cerebus, despite his stature in the church, enters this situation with a sense of despondency, basically faced with the choice of being the pawn of one of two groups. The progress of the trial does nothing to ease anyone's mind, with a high concentration of tension and a bit of apparently mystical interference. The tall, narrow panels that served to so well in the chase sequence earlier return, giving a choppy, intercut feeling to a scene that basically devolves into the various involved figures yelling, shouting, fighting and trying their best to force their will on the goings-on. Cerebus has a vision, apparently shared with Astoria, in which their genders and species are reversed, apparently an echo of earlier, pre-Ascension trial involving Suentues Po (the illusionist that Cerebus has had some form of psychic contact with). As the trial progresses, Cirinist infiltrators of the church are busy sending word of the outcome to Cirin, who is revealed to be the second of three aardvarks supposedly at large in Estarcion.
With the trial devolving into an increasingly obscene affair, Weisshaupt's final post-mortem assistance arrives: a solid-gold sphere tucked behind the throne of the chamber; the final ingredient of the Ascension. Cerebus sheds his robes and runs for the black tower in the Upper City, which is rumoured to be the vehicle for ascending to Vanaheim.
And this is where things get REALLY crazy.
Short version: Cerebus ascends, in the hollow of the black tower that splits from the mountain and rises into the sky. But of course, its' not that easy. On his way, he is distracted by surreal figures (including a guest appearance by 80's indie comics hero Flaming Carrot!) who try to turn him back. But he makes it to the peak of the tower, and defeats the three-headed apocalypse beast from earlier (who arrived with his/her/it's own gold sphere), only to arrive...
On the Moon? Not exactly Vanaheim, and the black-clad figure he meets is not the expected deity Tarim, but instead an entity known as the Judge. But he does have quite a bit of information to impart to Cerebus.
And yes, here comes the SPOILER!!!!!
No, seriously. I'm spoiling the end of the book. Don't look.
Ok. The Judge gives Cerebus a bit of a history lesson as a preamble...including the history of Suentues Po in his various past lives, the fate of various ascensions (and the fact that he was hoping it would be Weisshaupt who finally managed to pull it off), the eventual fate of the world (someone pushes a button and blows up the sun), and Cerebus' fate.
Cerebus never conquers the known world. He never amasses all the gold in Estarcion. He lives only a short time longer, and dies. Alone, unmourned and unloved. And as an afterthought, the Judge tells Cerebus that if he ever feels this is undeserved, he should remember his second marriage (to Astoria).
Cheery stuff, huh?
Interesting that 1200 pages of comics, or actually, the entirety of the series thus far, however many pages that may be, culminates with the denunciation and condemnation of the title character. Who will continue to serve as the protagonist for the next 175 or so issues. Not that I'm really complaining. Along the way, there's a lot of boundary-pushing, unique, and amazing work. Of course, there's a lot of frustratingly awful material as well....but that doesn't really start for a while still.
The final piece of
Church & State is the double-issue epilogue story that appears in
Cerebus Number Zero, titled "Square One". Cerebus finds himself back in Iest, at his commanderred hotel. The tower has destroyed much of the lower city (again), and the Cirinists seized the moment to invade, easily taking control of Iest. Cerebus contemplates suicide after a brief trip through the hotel, still filled with reminders of his failings (and, of course, looted of his amassed gold). There's no clear indication of how long he was gone, but it's long enough for things to have settled into a dreary, totalitarian routine. Dazed and discouraged, he wanders off into the city.
And on that note of introspection, we come to the most introspective, withdrawn volume so far:
Jaka's Story. Y'all come back now, y'hear?